For teams that want focused AI search work without paid-media bundling, AY Rank is the stronger pick: a GEO-first programme from $1,700 per month and faster onboarding. Directive Consulting is the stronger pick when you want SEO, paid media, and RevOps run together at enterprise scale. The side-by-side below covers methodology, pricing, reporting, and speed.
If you are evaluating Directive Consulting against AY Rank for your AI search and GEO program, this comparison gives you a structured side-by-side. We will be fair to Directive Consulting: they are a credible operator with real wins. We will also be specific about where AY Rank takes a different approach and why it matters.
Quick Take
Choose Directive Consulting if: you want a single agency to run paid, SEO, and CRO under one roof
Choose AY Rank if: you want a specialist GEO/AI search program, not a full-funnel marketing engagement
Both can deliver results. The question is which methodology matches your situation.
About Directive Consulting
Directive Consulting is a performance marketing agency focused on B2B SaaS, with strong capabilities in paid search, SEO, and conversion rate optimization. They are based in California and serve mid-market to enterprise SaaS clients with full-funnel programs that include media buying, content, and analytics.
About AY Rank
AY Rank is a specialist GEO (Generative Engine Optimization) and AI search agency. We focus exclusively on getting brands cited by ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, and AI Overviews. Pricing runs $1,700 to $4,500 per month. Programs combine entity engineering, structured data, citation-ready content, listicle authority, and weekly tracking across 5 AI platforms.
Our wins include Wearview going from $0 to $36K MRR in 8 months; the full stories are on our case studies page.
Methodology Comparison
| Dimension | Directive Consulting | AY Rank |
|---|
| Primary focus | Full-funnel performance marketing | GEO + AI citation only |
| Services bundled | Paid + SEO + CRO + analytics | GEO methodology, focused |
| Pricing range | Not published (custom quotes) | $1,700-$4,500/mo |
| AI platforms tracked | Emerging coverage | 5: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, DeepSeek |
| Onboarding | 30-60 days | 10-14 days |
| Best fit | Mid-market to enterprise SaaS needing full funnel | Brands that already have media + want AI layer |
Where Directive Consulting Excels
- you want a single agency to run paid, SEO, and CRO under one roof
- Full-funnel B2B SaaS expertise (paid + organic + CRO)
- Strong analytics and attribution stack
- Experienced media buyers and CRO specialists in-house
- Larger team with capacity for enterprise programs